Why Soft 404s Are Bad: Explained by Google

broken image

Introduction

In the world of SEO and website management, understanding the nuances of HTTP status codes is crucial for maintaining a healthy site. One particular status code, or rather its improper implementation, that can cause significant issues is the "soft 404." According to Google, soft 404s are detrimental to your website’s performance, user experience, and search engine ranking. This article delves into what soft 404s are, why they are problematic, and how you can address them to improve your site’s overall health.

Understanding HTTP Status Codes

HTTP status codes are responses given by a server to a client's request made to the server. They help in understanding what happened with a particular request. Here’s a brief overview of some common status codes:

  • 200 OK: The request was successful.
  • 301 Moved Permanently: The resource has been moved to a different URL.
  • 404 Not Found: The server can’t find the requested resource.
  • 500 Internal Server Error: The server encountered an unexpected condition.

What Is a Soft 404?

A soft 404 occurs when a web server returns a "200 OK" status code for a page that does not actually exist. Instead of a proper "404 Not Found" error, the server delivers a 200 status code along with a page that might display a message like "Page not found" or redirects to another page, such as the homepage.

Example of Soft 404

Imagine you have a URL on your website that no longer exists, like www.example.com/old-page. When a user or a search engine crawler requests this URL, instead of receiving a 404 error, the server returns a 200 status code and displays a custom error page or redirects to another page.

Why Soft 404s Are Bad

Google has emphasized the importance of correctly handling 404 errors. Here are the main reasons why soft 404s are problematic:

1. Misleading Status Codes

Soft 404s send the wrong signal to search engines. When a non-existent page returns a 200 status code, it indicates to search engines that the page exists and is valid. As a result, search engines may continue to index and attempt to rank these non-existent pages, wasting valuable crawl budget and potentially harming your site's SEO.

2. Wasting Crawl Budget

Crawl budget refers to the number of pages a search engine crawler will scan and index on your site within a given timeframe. Soft 404s can waste this budget by leading crawlers to pages that should not be indexed. This inefficiency can prevent important, real content from being discovered and indexed.

3. Poor User Experience

Soft 404s can confuse and frustrate users. When users encounter a page that returns a 200 status code but provides a "Page not found" message, they may feel misled. This can lead to increased bounce rates and a negative perception of your site, ultimately affecting user engagement and satisfaction.

4. Negative Impact on SEO

Search engines aim to provide users with the most relevant and accurate search results. Soft 404s can harm your site's credibility and authority, as search engines may perceive your site as less reliable. This can result in lower rankings and decreased organic traffic.

5. Difficult to Identify and Fix

Unlike standard 404 errors, which are easy to identify through server logs and error reports, soft 404s require more effort to detect. They often necessitate a thorough review of server responses and content to pinpoint the issues, making the process of correcting them more complex and time-consuming.

Google’s Perspective on Soft 404s

Google’s webmaster guidelines and best practices emphasize the importance of correct HTTP status codes for effective crawling and indexing. Google uses a variety of signals to determine whether a page is a soft 404, including the content of the page and how users interact with it.

Google Search Console and Soft 404s

Google Search Console is a valuable tool for identifying soft 404 errors. In the "Coverage" report, Google flags pages that it considers to be soft 404s. These notifications help webmasters address and correct issues promptly, ensuring that their site remains in good standing with Google’s indexing and ranking algorithms.

Recommendations from Google

Google recommends the following practices to avoid soft 404 errors:

  • Return the Correct Status Code: For pages that do not exist, ensure your server returns a proper 404 (Not Found) or 410 (Gone) status code.
  • Custom 404 Pages: Create a custom 404 page that is helpful and user-friendly. This page should clearly inform users that the page they are looking for does not exist and provide links to other parts of your site.
  • Fix Broken Links: Regularly audit your site to identify and fix broken links that may lead to non-existent pages.
  • Proper Redirects: Use 301 redirects for permanently moved content and 302 redirects for temporary moves to guide users and search engines to the correct pages.

How to Identify and Fix Soft 404s

Tools for Identification

Several tools can help you identify soft 404 errors on your website:

  1. Google Search Console: As mentioned, the "Coverage" report in Google Search Console can flag soft 404 errors.
  2. Crawling Tools: Tools like Screaming Frog SEO Spider, Ahrefs, and SEMrush can crawl your site and identify pages that may be returning incorrect status codes.
  3. Server Logs: Reviewing server logs can help identify requests for non-existent pages and the status codes returned by the server.
Steps to Fix Soft 404s
  1. Audit Your Site: Use the tools mentioned above to conduct a comprehensive audit of your site. Identify pages that are returning 200 status codes but should return 404 or 410 status codes.
  2. Update Server Responses: Configure your server to return the correct status codes for non-existent pages. Ensure that 404 and 410 errors are properly handled.
  3. Create Custom 404 Pages: Design a custom 404 page that is informative and user-friendly. Include navigation links to guide users to other parts of your site.
  4. Implement Proper Redirects: For pages that have moved permanently, use 301 redirects. For temporary moves, use 302 redirects. Avoid blanket redirects to the homepage as this can be seen as a soft 404 by Google.
  5. Monitor and Maintain: Regularly monitor your site for new soft 404 errors. Use Google Search Console and other tools to stay informed about any issues and address them promptly.

Best Practices to Prevent Soft 404s

Implementing the following best practices can help prevent soft 404 errors and maintain a healthy website:

Regular Site Audits

Conduct regular audits of your website to identify and address any issues that may arise. Use tools like Google Search Console, Screaming Frog, and Ahrefs to keep track of your site's health and ensure that it is free from soft 404 errors.

Proper Content Management

Maintain a robust content management strategy to ensure that all pages on your site are relevant, up-to-date, and accessible. Remove or update outdated content and ensure that all links are functioning correctly.

User-Friendly 404 Pages

Design custom 404 pages that provide helpful information and guide users to other parts of your site. Include navigation links, search functionality, and a clear message that informs users that the page they are looking for does not exist.

Correct Use of Redirects

Use 301 redirects for permanently moved content and 302 redirects for temporary moves. Avoid using blanket redirects to the homepage as this can confuse users and search engines.

Monitor Server Responses

Regularly monitor your server responses to ensure that they are returning the correct status codes. Use server logs and crawling tools to identify any discrepancies and address them promptly.

Conclusion

Soft 404s can have a significant negative impact on your website's performance, user experience, and SEO. By understanding what soft 404s are, why they are problematic, and how to address them, you can improve your site's overall health and ensure that it remains in good standing with search engines like Google.

Implementing best practices such as regular site audits, proper content management, user-friendly 404 pages, correct use of redirects, and monitoring server responses can help prevent soft 404 errors and maintain a healthy, high-performing website. By staying proactive and addressing issues promptly, you can enhance user experience, improve search engine rankings, and drive more organic traffic to your site.

Read More Articles: